Most people would agree that buildings represent a valuable record of any ã7`j’&def€¹forum.pre-mbaclub.com4K¨H ÂÝ
society s past, but controversy arises when old buildings stand on ground ã7`j’&def€¹forum.pre-mbaclub.com4K¨H ÂÝ
that modern planners feel could be better used for modern purposes. ã7`j’&def€¹forum.pre-mbaclub.com4K¨H ÂÝ
In your opinion, which is more important-preserving historic buildings or ã7`j’&def€¹forum.pre-mbaclub.com4K¨H ÂÝ
encouraging modern development? Explain your position, using reasons and ã7`j’&def€¹forum.pre-mbaclub.com4K¨H ÂÝ
examples based on your own experiences, observations, or reading. （新与 ã7`j’&def€¹forum.pre-mbaclub.com4K¨H ÂÝ
旧） ã7`j’&def€¹forum.pre-mbaclub.com4K¨H ÂÝ
ã7`j’&def€¹forum.pre-mbaclub.com4K¨H ÂÝ
The issue of whether to raze an old, historic building to make way for ã7`j’&def€¹forum.pre-mbaclub.com4K¨H ÂÝ
progress is a complex one, since it involves a conflict between our ã7`j’&def€¹forum.pre-mbaclub.com4K¨H ÂÝ
interest in preserving our culture, tradition, and history and a legitimate ã7`j’&def€¹forum.pre-mbaclub.com4K¨H ÂÝ
need to create practical facilities that serve current utilitarian ã7`j’&def€¹forum.pre-mbaclub.com4K¨H ÂÝ
purposes. In my view, the final judgment should depend on a case-by-case ã7`j’&def€¹forum.pre-mbaclub.com4K¨H ÂÝ
analysis of two key factors. ã7`j’&def€¹forum.pre-mbaclub.com4K¨H ÂÝ
One key factor is the historic value of the building. An older building may ã7`j’&def€¹forum.pre-mbaclub.com4K¨H ÂÝ
be worth saving because it uniquely represents some bygone era. On the ã7`j’&def€¹forum.pre-mbaclub.com4K¨H ÂÝ
other hand, if several older buildings represent the era just as ã7`j’&def€¹forum.pre-mbaclub.com4K¨H ÂÝ
effectively, then the historic value of one building might be negligible. ã7`j’&def€¹forum.pre-mbaclub.com4K¨H ÂÝ
If the building figured centrally into the city s history as a municipal ã7`j’&def€¹forum.pre-mbaclub.com4K¨H ÂÝ
structure, the home of a founding family or other significant historical ã7`j’&def€¹forum.pre-mbaclub.com4K¨H ÂÝ
figure, or the location of important events, then its historic value would ã7`j’&def€¹forum.pre-mbaclub.com4K¨H ÂÝ
be greater than if its history was an unremarkable one. ã7`j’&def€¹forum.pre-mbaclub.com4K¨H ÂÝ
The other key factor involves the specific utilitarian needs of the ã7`j’&def€¹forum.pre-mbaclub.com4K¨H ÂÝ
community and the relative costs and benefits of each alternative in light ã7`j’&def€¹forum.pre-mbaclub.com4K¨H ÂÝ
of those needs. For example, if the need is mainly for more office space, ã7`j’&def€¹forum.pre-mbaclub.com4K¨H ÂÝ
then an architecturally appropriate add-on or annex might serve just as ã7`j’&def€¹forum.pre-mbaclub.com4K¨H ÂÝ
well as a new building. On the other hand, an expensive retrofit may not be ã7`j’&def€¹forum.pre-mbaclub.com4K¨H ÂÝ
worthwhile if no amount of retrofitting would permit it to serve the ã7`j’&def€¹forum.pre-mbaclub.com4K¨H ÂÝ
desired function- Moreover, retrofitting might undermine the historic value ã7`j’&def€¹forum.pre-mbaclub.com4K¨H ÂÝ
of the old building by altering its aesthetic or architectural integrity. ã7`j’&def€¹forum.pre-mbaclub.com4K¨H ÂÝ
In sum, neither modernization for its own sake nor indiscriminate ã7`j’&def€¹forum.pre-mbaclub.com4K¨H ÂÝ
preservation of old buildings should guide decisions in the controversies ã7`j’&def€¹forum.pre-mbaclub.com4K¨H ÂÝ
at issue. Instead, decisions should be made on a case-by-case basis) ã7`j’&def€¹forum.pre-mbaclub.com4K¨H ÂÝ
considering historic value, community need, and the comparative costs and ã7`j’&def€¹forum.pre-mbaclub.com4K¨H ÂÝ
benefits of each alternativeã7`j’&def€¹forum.pre-mbaclub.com4K¨H ÂÝ